Previous post about John Kerry
            QUESTION from Henley on May 4, 2004

A previous post by Jonathan on April 23 asked about politicians who "unambiguously support abortion." He stated as fact that presidential candidate John Kerry falls into this camp and he seemed to support the notion of excommunicating Sen. Kerry. I think, to be fair, one should be aware that Sen. Kerry has not supported and and does not presently "support abortion." What John Kerry does support is allowing women to make their own choice regarding this very divisive issue over whether a woman should be compelled by law to support the life of another human being that grows within her. I agree that anyone who that would actively encourages people to choose abortion (as is implied by terms like "support for abortion" and "pro-abortion") would be committing very grave sin and we should pray for such people. Since Sen. Kerry, as well as most other pro-choice politicians, however, clearly do not fall into the category of advocating abortion, it is clear to me why they have NOT been excommunitcated and continue to receive the Sacrament of Communion. There is a world of difference between being "pro-abortion" and "pro-choice." Using myself as an example, I would never, under ANY circumstances (health of the mother, rape, etc.), consider the option of abortion for my wife or a loved one. Also, if consulted, I would strongly dissuade any family or loved one from looking to abortion as an answer to an unwanted pregnancy. If, however, I do not agree that a total ban on abortion should be the law of the land, does this make me sinful person? I just think that much more life can be saved by providing education, love, support, by setting positive examples and through charitable giving. Legislation on such an issue could result in division, animosity, and alienation and, in the end, not save lives as intended. I know many good Catholics and other Christians who believe the same. Thank you for this valuable forum.